By Ray Massey Updated: 02:54 EDT, 2 November 2024
Car makers are being forced to build thousands of electric vehicles that customers don’t want – and they face large fines if they don’t.That’s the strategy being pursued by the Government because of a green plan dreamed up by civil servants that could lead to a glut of expensive EVs. Further still, it could create a shortage of low-polluting, petrol-electric hybrids for which demand is booming, crash residual values and destroy what’s left of UK car manufacturing as China moves in to mop up.Ultimately, UK consumers will pay the price, along with motor industry workers and suppliers who face losing their jobs as factories are forced to close.But don’t take my word for it. Ask Labour peer and former trade union leader Lord Woodley of Wallasey, who has condemned the plan as ‘political suicide’. Sparking debate: Numbers don’t add up for electric vehiclesHe should know. As a teenager, Tony Woodley began his automotive career at Vauxhall’s Ellesmere Port plant in Merseyside.When I first met him in the mid-1990s, he was the hard-nosed but highly respected chief motor industry negotiator for the giant Transport and General Workers’ Union (TGWU), before becoming its general secretary from 2004 and joint general secretary of the Unite union from 2007 to 2011.Like industry bosses, he has stressed that moving towards an electric future is right – but what is wrong is the unsustainable timetable and draconian fines.This is about the Government’s Zero Emission Vehicle (ZEV) Mandate, which requires 22 per cent of all new cars sold to UK customers this year to be fully electric. That rises to 28 per cent next year then ever upwards to 100 per cent by 2035. Car makers are fined £15,000 for every non-EV vehicle sold up to the target number. ‘It is ridiculous,’ Lord Woodley told peers.So far, the industry is falling about 4 per cent short of that quota – on track for £1.4billion in fines. Car firms are already subsidising each EV by around £6,000, which Lord Woodley revealed adds another £2billion to costs.Fines can be offset by buying credits from manufacturers who exceed their EV targets – namely Chinese makers and the US brand Tesla.’The idea of UK manufacturers paying the Chinese or the Americans billions in credits is a nonsense and, I suggest, political suicide in automotive constituencies across the country,’ he added.’The market has collapsed, apart from fleet sales, so we need incentives both to build and to buy.’ Electric future: The ZEV mandate will force car makers to sell an increasing volume of EVs between now and 2035Instead, VAT on new electric cars should be reduced and VAT on public chargers should be lowered to equal that on private domestic chargers. The higher road tax on expensive car purchases should be scrapped and the ZEV mandate timetable ‘reset’ to realistic levels.Exported EVs and commercial vehicle EVs should be counted as ‘credits’.Two Vauxhall van plants – Ellesmere Port and Luton – are already ‘at serious risk of being closed’ because of this, he warned.Robert Forrester, boss of the car dealer Vertu, welcomed his comments, saying: ‘At last, Parliament has debated electric vehicles with a proper discussion on the damaging Zev Mandate.’ CARS & MOTORING: ON TEST Hyundai Inster review: Is it the affordable EV we’ve been waiting for? The most controversial new car of 2024: We drive the Ford Capri EV Aston Martin Vanquish: Britain’s new brute of a sports car tested Renault 5 EV: Can it recreate the character and charm of the original? Polestar 4 EV: The first car sold in Britain WITHOUT a rear window We take to the wheel of Ferrari’s stunning new £336k 12Cilindri GT car China’s new sub-£16k EV: Leapmotor T03 arrives in UK with low price Peugeot E-5008: Is the £49k SUV the choice for eco-conscious families? Ducati’s new £30,000 Panigale V4 S costs the same as a small Mercedes Is the new £22k MG ZS hybrid family-friendly SUV a genuine bargain? This £100k Volvo has driven me to distraction: EX90 SUV driven VW Touareg is a luxury SUV for a lower price – why is it so unpopular? We test the new MG HS – Britain’s favourite budget-friendly family SUV We test drive the £15,000 Dacia Spring – the UK’s CHEAPEST new EV Suitable for UK climates: You can enjoy Mercedes CLE Cabrio year round Kia’s affordable Picanto offers a fun and nippy drive in the big city MG Cyberster review – convertible EV costs £60k and is fun to drive ‘Euros’ winning Renault Scenic E-Tech gets Ray Massey’s vote Ford Explorer: Is the £40k electric SUV a good buy for UK drivers? Polestar 3: Does the Tesla Model Y now have a real fight on its hands? Lotus Eletre is an EV Lamborghini Urus rival: The hyper-SUV tested Dacia’s new Duster is here – has it lost its value-for-money appeal? Alfa Romeo Tonale review: Can this SUV bring some sporting thrill? In a world of SUVs, can the VW Passat re-energise the estate market? Ineos Quartermaster review: The new premium pick-up truck in town Peugeot e-3008 is attractive, sprightly and has a 326-mile range New £165k Aston Martin Vantage tested – is it better than a Ferrari? Can BMW harness the magic of the original Mini in an EV made in China? Is this the ultimate open-top super tourer? Aston Martin DB12 Volante New Fiat 600e EV family car is here, but should wait for the hybrid? VW Tiguan review: Brand’s best-selling SUV is back – but is it better? Should you consider the Mini Countryman EV instead of the petrol? Another BMW goes electric – we test the new iX2 vs its petrol X2 rival The 2024 Range Rover Evoque plug-in hybrid is a home-grown winner Britain’s favourite car DRIVEN – we review the best-selling Ford Puma BMW’s i5 EV offers supercar performance in an exec saloon package We drive the £76,000 Kia EV9 – Korea’s all-electric Range Rover rival Has the BMW M3 Touring been worth the three-decade wait? Our review Has Britain’s most popular small car just got much better? New Corsa Volvo EX30 review: Sweden’s new ‘green’ pocket rocket SUV rival Tesla Is Renault’s new Austral E-Tech SUV the complete package? We drive it The Audi Q8 is annoyingly good for a ‘sporty’ coupe-style SUV Ferrari Roma Spider costs £210k – here’s what you get for your money China’s all-electric BYD Dolphin lands ashore – we test it on UK roads Our epic road test through Demark and Sweden in the new Polestar 2 New Abarth 500e convertible is a rare treat – it’s electric and sporty Honda’s new CR-V is bigger than its predecessor – but is it better? We beat the new Bond to test his new car: Aston Martin DB12 review Behind the wheel of Rolls-Royce’s Spectre: We test the new EV Roller Skoda’s crowning glory: Superb L&K 4×4 Estate with extras driven Maserati Grecale test – the SUV with 50% of sales projected for women Dacia’s budget family car with seven seats! The £18,000 Jogger tested This Q8 is just great: We take Audi’s new Sportback e-tron for a spin Enter the Dragon! BYD Atto EV is the Chinese company’s first UK model Ferrari’s first four-door family car: New £313,000 Purosangue driven Thrills without frills: £31,000 MG5 is one of the cheapest family EVs Renault’s Arkana ticks all the boxes for what car-buying Britons want Can Peugeot’s chic 408 hybrid crossover be a hit in the UK? We test it We drive the Civic Type R – the rebellious bad boy in Honda’s line-up Rolls Royce Spectre: What’s it lke to drive the first ELECTRIC Roller? Ineos Grenadier driven: Sir Jim Ratcliffe’s £69,000 Defender Can you really live with a tiny Citroen Ami? Seven tasks in seven days Don’t supersize me! Is the ‘smaller’ Volvo XC60 all the SUV you need? We pamper some passengers in the new £211k Bentley Bentayga New kind of Buzz! VW’s electric MPV still feels like a hippy campervan
Share or comment on this article:
RAY MASSEY: How I wish they’d scrap crazy electric car quotas
Some links in this article may be affiliate links. If you click on them we may earn a small commission. That helps us fund This Is Money, and keep it free to use. We do not write articles to promote products. We do not allow any commercial relationship to affect our editorial independence.